Why Christian Movies Are Terrible

I know, I know. Outrage. But before you grab your pitchfork, hear me out. Blanket statements aside, I think we can admit that many of the Christian movies released in the last ten years have failed the test of good media, and not just because their budgets were so small.

Let's get back to this guy. At least he had chops.
Let’s bring back this guy. He had chops.

I think the reason for this lies in the way we think about worldview, and the communication of a worldview. Worldview, as I’ve said before, consists of four interlocking components: catechesis, narrative, liturgy, and lifestyle. Catechesis is our propositional instruction, the content of our beliefs. Those beliefs are codified in our catechesis, but imagined, imaged in our narratives. If catechesis is the brain of a worldview, then narrative is its soul. The stories that we tell about ourselves, our origins, our heroes– these influence us in profound ways, possibly more than we realize.

We must realize that catechesis and narrative, though they overlap, though they communicate the same realities, are different modes of expressing those realities. They communicate the same truths in different ways, as they are intended to do. Catechesis can utilize narrative, but it needs to be propositional. Imagine if all we had were stories, with no statements about the meaning or morality of those stories. Discerning the truth would nearly be an impossibility. Likewise, narratives can be (and should be) catechetical, but they cannot capture our hearts and imaginations with the same degree of potency if they are primarily so. Stories make us yearn for realities which our catechesis tells us we should yearn for. Stories make us hate the things we ought to hate, and love the things we ought to love. It does this better than instruction, because it was designed to do this better than instruction.

Many Christian movies, I find, are doctrinal statements (and poor ones at that) with a thin veneer of story overtop. They cannot make me love the things I ought to love, because the story is so anemic. I admire the desire of these filmmakers to have a Christian presence in the industry, and I admire their commitment to Christian truth. But their product cannot do what they want it to do (that is, capture the hearts of their audience) because they aren’t telling stories; they’re giving expensive multi-media devotionals. To adapt Lewis, “The world does not need more Christian movies. What it needs is more Christians making good movies.”

4 thoughts on “Why Christian Movies Are Terrible

  1. bob stanley

    i never watched them anyway, always a distortion,and not the “Word” which makes them unprofitable,exception being the “The Passion” mel gibsons creation.which left me shaken at the beating Christ took. very realistic

  2. You should check out Cave Pictures, a corrective to just what you’re talking about. Our current four films are “Wildflower,” a psychological thriller that was just released on DVD and streaming last month; “The Ticket,” starring Dan Stevens, which premiered at Tribeca last month and is securing distribution now; “Waiting for the Miracle to Come,” starring Charlotte Rampling and Willie Nelson, which is in post; and Martin Scorsese’s adaptation of Shusaku Endo’s “Silence,” about two young priests who sneak into Japan during a time of intense persecution in the early 17th century. The film stars Andrew Garfield and Adam Driver as the two young priests, and Liam Neeson as the lost mentor they are trying to find. Though the release date hasn’t been officially announced yet, Paramount Pictures will likely be releasing the film this Christmas.

  3. Pingback: The Stories We Tell– Redux – Cultus and Culture

  4. Pingback: Art as Discipleship Pt. 2 – Cultus and Culture

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s